Searching Introduction
Introduction to the binary search algorithm, it's uses, advantages, and disadvantages
What is searching?
In certain computer programs and applications, one might find the need to locate and retrieve a data value and/or it's index. Searching algorithms could be done in either intervals or sequences, and certain algorithms could be more efficient than others, with benefits and drawbacks to each.
Searching Notes:
- Two main kinds fo searching:
- Sequential search:
- takes the length of the list operations to execute
- Iteratively going through each element of a list
- can use for loop
- while loop
- recursive function
- Takes more time, as it must look through every element of the list
- can be used in an unsorted order
- Binary Search:
- ONLY can be used with sorted arrays
- takes log base 2 times the length of list operations(less than sequential search)
- can be done with a while loop or a recursive function
- with each call, it uses a min and max value to throw out half of the array each time
- it uses a mid value with indexes to accomplish this.
- Sequential search:
The Naive Approach
The most intuitively obvious solution to the searching problem is to sequentialy check each successful value in the data structure until either a matching value is found, or the entire structure has been transversed. This thought process could be explained graphically in this example
def sequentialSearch(arr, target):
N = len(arr) # Declare N as length of array
for i in range(N): # Iterate over the list
if arr[i] == target: # Check for match
return i # Match found, return index and end function call
return -1 # Element not found
Sequential Search - Larger Inputs
Although for selection sort is seemingly fast for smaller inputs, it is clear that it cannot keep up with increasing input sizes. Because sequential search checks every value of the given array, the algorithm's overall runtime increases "linearly" with the input size.
i.e. Pretend that one check takes one second, and that we are searching for the last element in an array. If the array length is 4, it would take 4 seconds to find the last element, whereas if the array length is 86400 indices long, it would take a whole day to find the element.
Hence, although selection sort is known for its simplicity, it is unfeasible for large inputs
Below, we have created three sorted lists of length 100,1000000,100000000.
import time
arr1 = [i for i in range(100)]
arr2 = [i for i in range(1000000)]
arr3 = [i for i in range(100000000)]
To analyze the sequential search algorithm, we will check for the worst case scenario, where runtime is maximized. This is because when measuring the efficiency of our algorithm, we want to be able to guarantee an upper limit or set amount of time for our program to finish running. To do this, we will attempt to search for the last element in the array
print("length of list: ", len(arr1))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", sequentialSearch(arr1,99))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
print("length of list: ", len(arr2))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", sequentialSearch(arr2,999999))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
print("length of list: ", len(arr3))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", sequentialSearch(arr3,99999999))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
As you can see, as the input list grows larger and larger, the overall runtime of the program increases linearly as well, resulting in a lower scalability for the sequential search algorithm.
Binary Search
Binary search is an efficient way to iterate through a SORTED list to find a requested value. This is done through checking the middle value of a list and checking if the requested value is greater than or less than the middle value. You can start to see why the requested list must be sorted. If the list is not sorted, this logic is flawed, and the binary search algorithm will no longer work.
Unlike the sequential search method, binary search doesn't check for each successive element until a match is found. In every iteration the algorithm is making a binary decision; if the selected element is larger or smaller than the target.
How exactly does this work? Lets look at these amazing ms paint drawings:
i was too lazy to make a third so ur gonna have to live with 2 :)
This algorithm is extremely efficient as the maximum number of cycles in binary search is equal to log base 2 of the closest, next power of two, to length of list.
If the array is 8 items long, the maximum possible cycles would be 3 (log base 2 of 8 is 3)
If the array is 7 items long, the maximum possible cycles would STILL be 3 as the closest power of 2 to 7 is 8.
If the array is 9 items long, the maximum possible cycles INCREASES to 4, as the closest, next power of two, is 16.
def binarySearch(array, target): # Parameters: array is the given array and target is what we are looking for
low = 0 # the starting lower bound
high = len(array)-1 # the starting upper bound
while high >= low: # we will keep running until we run out of possible subarrays...
mid = (high + low) // 2 # define the middle of the list to be the item at the index of the average of the lower and upper bound
if array[mid] == target: # if item is in the middle of the list... we found what we are looking for!
return mid # therefore, we return the index of where we found the item.
elif array[mid] > target: # if item is less than the middle of the list, this must mean that the item is on the lower half of the list
high = mid-1 # therefore, we set the upper bound of the search to be the last item of the lower half
else: # if item is neither less than or equal to the middle of the list, this must mean that the item is on the upper half of the list
low = mid+1 # therefore, we set the lower bound of the search to be the first item of the upper half
# if nothing is returned by the time the while loop ends, that means item MUST be missing from list
return False # therefore we tell the user that the requested item was not found
Likewise, we can also take a recursive approach to this problem, note the similarities
def BinarySearchRecursion(arr, target, lo, hi):
if lo > hi:
return False
mid = (lo+hi)//2
if arr[mid] == target:
return mid
elif arr[mid] > target:
return BinarySearchRecursion(arr, target, lo, mid-1)
elif arr[mid] < target:
return BinarySearchRecursion(arr, target, mid+1, hi)
Now, let's compare the runtime with the same lists we tried with the sequential search algorithm.
print("length of list: ", len(arr1))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", binarySearch(arr1,99))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
print("length of list: ", len(arr2))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", binarySearch(arr2,999999))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
print("length of list: ", len(arr3))
s = time.time()
print("Index: ", binarySearch(arr3,99999999))
e = time.time()
print('Execution time:', (e-s)*1000, 'ms')
arr4 = [1,4,5,8,10,13,145,1938]
print("Index: ", binarySearch(arr4,17))
Challenges and Homework
You have one homework problem.
Yes just one.
Don't get excited though.
Problem: Given a specific integer N, return the square root of N (R) if N is a perfect square, otherwise, return the square root of N rounded down to the nearest integer
Input: N (Integer)
Output: R (Integer)
Constraints: Do not use any built-in math operations such as sqrt(x) or x**(0.5), Try complete the problem in logarithmic time.
Hint 1: Maybe you can use Binary Search to try and reduce the number of checks you have to perform?
Hint 2: Is there a mathematical pattern amongst numbers and their square roots that could help you reduce the number of searches or iterations you must execute? Is there some value or rule you can set before applying binary search to narrow the range of possible values?
Run the very last code segment below to load test cases and submission function
def sqrt(N):
max = N
min = 0
mid = 0
while True:
mid = (min+max)//2
if mid**2 < N:
min = mid+1
elif mid**2 > N:
max = mid
else:
return mid
from math import sqrt as sq
test_cases = [0,1,4,85248289,22297284,18939904,91107025,69122596,9721924,37810201,1893294144,8722812816,644398225]
answers = [int(sq(x)) for x in test_cases]
def checkValid():
for i in range(len(test_cases)):
if sqrt(test_cases[i]) == answers[i]:
print("Check number {} passed".format(i+1))
else:
print("Check number {} failed".format(i+1))
checkValid()